Samuel Alito's Judicial Philosophy

Host / other voice

“the court has taken upon itself the power and authority to say what the reconstruction amendments mean and to say whether and how, if at all, they have continuing relevance to the landscape of this country.”

Host / other voice

“These discussions that have such prominent place in Samuel Alito's dissenting opinion of so-called birth tourism will... fuel incremental immigration restrictions as this movement like the abortion opposition movement is rooted in anxieties about demographic change.”

Samuel Alito

“this is one of the most important decisions in the history of the court. And in my judgment, the court has made a serious, serious mistake, just like they did with Dred Scott, just like they did with Roe v. Wade, et cetera.”

Host / other voice

“Samuel Alito said the 14th Amendment was misinterpreted by the majority opinion. He said the 14th Amendment was meant to mirror the 1866 Civil Rights Act, which conferred citizenship to former enslaved African Americans. It excluded American Indians and the children of diplomats.”

Host / other voice

“He also spent time talking about birth tourism. This is also something President Trump's worried about the idea that wealthy people are coming to the country just to have a baby who becomes a citizen and then leaving without loyalty or allegiance to the country.”

Host / other voice

“Samuel Alito Lido, he said that the court basically made a serious mistake with this decision. He said that when the 14th Amendment was adopted, that it was really meant only for children who at birth owe an allegiance to the United States.”

Host / other voice

“I think there's a really good argument why some members of this group who have lived here for years have a strong moral claim to be able to remain in the land where they grew up. And Congress should address that question.”

Samuel Alito

“As interpreted by the court today, the 14th Amendment confers citizenship on virtually everyone who happens to be born in this country, including the children of birth tourists, women who come here solely for the purpose of giving birth to a child and then promptly return home.”

Samuel Alito

“In my judgment, the court has made a mistake that will seriously affect the country's future. Suppose that a person's only connection to this country is that he was born here to a mother who was present just long enough to give birth and then quickly returned to her native country. Suppose that country is a strategic adversary or enemy of the United States. Suppose the child never visited the United States and was inculcated with hatred of this country. According to this court, now that person is a citizen of the United States. He can enter and leave the country as he pleases. He can travel the world on a U.S. passport. Even if he plots to harm this country, he cannot be deprived of his status as a citizen, at least under current precedent.”

Host / other voice

“So in a 6-3 court, which is what we've hoped and presumed this would be, and in some cases has been, in a 6-3 court, we can count on Roberts as often as not to side with the left, giving us a 5-4 majority, and then when they peel Amy Coney-Barritt away, here's where we end up. That's just very, very... Very disappointing.”

Host / other voice

“Samuel Alito Samuel Alito said that the state law in Hawaii violates the second and 14th Amendment rights of gun owners because it prohibits them from concealing their weapons under their permits in places they would go in daily life, such as the gas stations, the convenience stores and restaurants.”

Host / other voice

“Samuel Alito Samuel Alito, writing for the majority, said Congress barred courts from reviewing decisions to extend or terminate TPS and found Haitian plaintiffs' racial discrimination claims weren't strong enough to justify a lower court injunction.”