Gretchen Whitmer on Jobs & Manufacturing
Michigan Manufacturing Jobs Plummet Under Whitmer
Job losses in Michigan have escalated dramatically under Gretchen Whitmer's administration, with reports indicating a loss of 36,000 jobs over the past year, including 18,000 manufacturing positions. Critics have pointed to her policies, particularly in the electric vehicle sector, as contributing to these declines, with General Motors cutting thousands of jobs in the state. Whitmer's handling of economic issues has faced scrutiny, with many questioning her focus and effectiveness amid rising unemployment rates and factory closures. The overall tone of the coverage has been critical, framing her leadership as ineffective in addressing the state's economic challenges.
See the 23 receipts behind this ↓The Receipts
On-the-record lines behind the coverage of Gretchen Whitmer on Jobs & Manufacturing — each links to the exact moment in the audio.
“I was happy to see today we finally killed Gretchen Whitmer's big job development program, which was paying billions of dollars to big, some of the most connected corporations in Michigan to build electric battery plants.”
“The vetoes drew sharp criticism for major labor organizations, including the Michigan AFL-CIO, UAW, and Michigan Education Association, which accused the governor of abandoning Michigan workers and betraying longtime political allies.”
“Standing by his side, then Governor Gretchen Whitmer, who also promoted it, S.K. Siltron took $1.5 million from taxpayers through the Michigan Business Development Program and nearly $6 million in tax incentives and promised to create 150 jobs.”
“Listen to Governor Gretchen Whitmer yesterday talking about what's happening in Michigan. Michigan is open for business. New factories making batteries, cars, ships are opening in Marshall, Lake Orion, Holland, Bay City, Calumet, Hemlock, Ann Arbor and Delta Township.”
“Governor Gretchen Whitmer said clean energy was going to be the future of Michigan jobs, solar and wind. Now people are saying maybe it's going to be AI, and it's extremely interesting.”
“Bridge is, you know, generally I would argue is left of center. And they published a story looking at her corporate welfare schemes and looked at the jobs that were promised and the money that was doled out in corporate welfare versus the reality.”
“Michigan is open for business. New factories making batteries, cars, chips. Probably not on the bingo car, but I want to thank President Trump for his work on this. How about that? Governor Gretchen Whitmer.”
“Governor Gretchen Whitmer highlighted the economic impact, including 2,500 construction jobs and hundreds of permanent positions along with new community investments.”
“A new poll finds Gretchen Whitmer's job approval rating plummeting from 52% to 43% just since February.”
“Gretchen Whitmer had said, hey, we need to be the clean energy state. The new jobs for Michigan need to come from things like solar and wind.”
“Governor Gretchen Whitmer bragging about adding 13 new jobs here in Michigan after our state has lost 20,000 so far this year.”
“her whole strategy has been, let's give corporate welfare to companies and create a thousand jobs here, 2,500 jobs there”
How each side frames it
Center-leaning outlets drive 92.2% of coverage.
Media tone toward Gretchen Whitmer on this issue, split by the leaning of the outlets covering it.
Coverage Volume
Episodes on this issue, per month · click a bar to jump to its story
Tone Trajectory
Media tone on this issue, per month — green favorable, red critical
Month by Month
Bridge Opening Sparks Job Debate
The opening of the Gordy Howe International Bridge was framed as a symbol of Michigan's partnership with Canada, with Gretchen Whitmer showcasing a Michigan-made Mustang convertible. However, her administration faced criticism from Republican candidates who argued that her policies have stifled investment in the auto industry, overshadowing her achievements. Additionally, discussions around Michigan's declining unemployment rates linked her repeal of the right-to-work law to economic improvements, but concerns about her overall governance and its impact on the labor market persisted.
Job Losses Spark Criticism of Leadership
The closure of the SK Siltron semiconductor facility in Michigan, which had received state incentives during Whitmer's tenure, has intensified scrutiny of her economic policies. Critics argue that this shutdown exemplifies the failures of Democratic leadership in addressing job creation and economic stability, linking high unemployment rates to her governance. Additionally, her recent vetoes of key legislation aimed at supporting workers have drawn backlash from labor organizations, further framing her administration as ineffective in fostering a robust manufacturing sector.
AI Data Center Promises Jobs Amid Criticism
A significant AI-focused data center project in Saline Township was endorsed by Gretchen Whitmer, who touted its potential to create 2,500 construction jobs and hundreds of permanent positions, framing it as a historic investment for Michigan. However, the project faced pushback from residents concerned about environmental impacts and transparency, highlighting a tension between economic development and community concerns. Additionally, the completion of the Gordy Howe International Bridge was presented as a transformative economic opportunity, although Whitmer's administration faced criticism regarding broader issues like unemployment and city services.
Criticism of Whitmer's Business Climate Grows
Gretchen Whitmer faced significant criticism regarding Michigan's business environment, with Rep. Gina Johnson asserting that her administration's regulations have stifled investment and job creation. Despite these challenges, Whitmer has been recognized for her efforts to attract new factories in the automotive and battery sectors, although progress on addressing the aging population's impact on the labor force remains slow. The discourse reflects a complex landscape where economic development initiatives are juxtaposed with concerns over governance and demographic challenges.
Approval Ratings Plummet Amid Criticism
Gretchen Whitmer's job approval rating has dropped significantly, reflecting growing dissatisfaction among Michigan residents regarding her leadership on jobs and manufacturing. Critics have pointed to ineffective state spending and unfulfilled promises related to employment growth, particularly in light of her self-assessment of her tenure as overly optimistic. The tone of the coverage suggests a mounting skepticism about her policies, especially concerning corporate welfare and infrastructure improvements.
Critics Slam Whitmer's Job Strategy
Gretchen Whitmer faced significant criticism for her reliance on corporate welfare to attract businesses, which has not led to substantial job creation amid ongoing job losses in Michigan. Despite her claims of adding 13 new jobs, the state has seen a net loss of 20,000 jobs this year, raising doubts about her economic policies. Additionally, scrutiny intensified over her administration's handling of unemployment overpayments during the pandemic, further complicating her economic narrative.
Job Losses Spark Whitmer Backlash
Criticism of Gretchen Whitmer intensified as Michigan faced significant job losses, with reports indicating a decline of 36,000 jobs over the past year. Opponents framed her administration's policies as detrimental to the state's economy, citing a proposed $800 million tax hike and a substantial budget increase despite declining revenues. Amidst this backdrop, some discussions acknowledged positive developments in new industries, yet the prevailing tone remained one of discontent regarding her handling of jobs and manufacturing.
Whitmer's Economic Strategy Under Fire
Gretchen Whitmer faced intense scrutiny over her administration's handling of economic policies, particularly regarding electric vehicle battery plants that failed to materialize despite substantial taxpayer funding. Critics highlighted the collapse of the Goshen Battery Plant project and the closure of an EV supplier, framing these failures as indicative of a broader ineffectiveness in her economic strategy. The tone of the coverage suggested growing frustration with her governance, as her efforts to attract businesses through incentives were increasingly questioned amidst rising job losses in the sector.
Manufacturing Jobs Plummet Under Whitmer
Michigan faces a significant downturn in manufacturing jobs, with estimates indicating a loss of 18,000 positions under Gretchen Whitmer's leadership. Critics have highlighted rising unemployment rates and the closure of key businesses, questioning the effectiveness of her economic policies and proposals, such as increasing the corporate tax rate. The coverage paints a bleak picture of the state's economic performance, suggesting that Whitmer's focus on national issues may have detracted from addressing local job losses.
Events & Actions
The factual record behind the coverage — discrete actions and events, dated and linked to the episode they aired on.
- Defunding of Gretchen Whitmer's job development program for electric battery plants.Hugh Hewitt Show
- Gretchen Whitmer promoted the SK Siltron semiconductor manufacturing facility.Justin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
- Gretchen Whitmer announced new factories opening in Michigan.Brian Kilmeade Show
- Gretchen Whitmer's job approval rating dropped significantly.Justin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
- Governor Gretchen Whitmer announced the addition of 13 new jobs in Michigan.Justin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
- presiding over job losses in MichiganJustin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
- Governor Gretchen Whitmer presiding over job losses in MichiganJustin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
- Gretchen Whitmer announced new factories and job opportunities in Michigan.Brian Kilmeade Show
- Gretchen Whitmer failed to secure battery factories for Michigan.The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show
- Gretchen Whitmer's electric vehicle mandates failed, leading to plant closures and layoffs.Justin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
- General Motors announced cuts to EV jobs, impacting Michigan.Justin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
- Coles Quality Foods closing, resulting in job lossesJustin Barclay (NewsRadio WOOD, Grand Rapids)
Where It Aired
Shows split by their average tone toward Gretchen Whitmer on this issue.